Your privacy, your choice

We use essential cookies to make sure the site can function. We also use optional cookies for advertising, personalisation of content, usage analysis, and social media.

By accepting optional cookies, you consent to the processing of your personal data - including transfers to third parties. Some third parties are outside of the European Economic Area, with varying standards of data protection.

See our privacy policy for more information on the use of your personal data.

for further information and to change your choices.
Skip to main content

Table 3 Methodological quality ratings using EPHPP criteria

From: A systematic review of interventions that impact alcohol and other drug-related harms in licensed entertainment settings and outdoor music festivals

Study

Selection bias

Study design

Confounders

Blinding*

Data Collection

Withdrawals *

Global rating

Archer et al. 2012 [50]

S

W

W

N/A

S

N/A

W

Athanasopoulos et al. 2021 [51]

S

M

M

N/A

M

N/A

S

Baldin et al. 2018 [52]

S

S

S

M

M

W

M

Bassols et al. 2018 [53]

S

M

S

N/A

S

N/A

S

Bernat et al. 2013 [54]

S

M

M

N/A

S

N/A

S

Brännström et al. 2016 [55]

S

W

M

N/A

M

N/A

M

Briggs et al. 2014 [56]

S

M

M

N/A

M

N/A

S

Brown et al. 2011 [57]

M

W

W

N/A

M

N/A

W

Burgason et al. 2017 [58]

S

M

M

N/A

S

N/A

S

Carvalho et al. 2014 [59]

M

W

W

N/A

M

N/A

W

Chamlin et al. 2014 [60]

S

M

S

N/A

M

N/A

S

Charlebois et al. 2017 [61]

W

M

S

W

S

N/A

W

Coomber et al. 2021 [62]

S

M

M

N/A

S

N/A

S

Curtis et al. 2017 [63]

S

M

M

N/A

M

N/A

S

Curtis et al. 2019 [64]

S

M

M

N/A

S

N/A

S

Curtis et al. 2019 [29]

S

W

W

N/A

M

N/A

W

Curtis et al. 2019 [30]

M

W

W

N/A

M

N/A

W

Curtis et al. 2021 [65]

S

M

W

N/A

S

N/A

M

de Andrade et al. 2016 [25]

S

M

S

N/A

S

N/A

S

de Andrade et al. 2021 [66]

S

M

M

N/A

S

N/A

S

de Goeij et al. 2015 [67]

S

M

S

N/A

M

N/A

S

de Vocht et al. 2016 [68]

S

M

M

N/A

S

N/A

S

de Vocht et al. 2017 [69]

S

M

M

N/A

M

N/A

S

de Vocht et al. 2017 [70]

S

M

S

N/A

S

N/A

S

de Vocht et al. 2020 [71]

S

S

S

N/A

S

N/A

S

Devilly et al. 2019 [72]

S

W

M

N/A

M

N/A

M

Donnelly et al. 2017 [73]

S

M

M

N/A

M

N/A

S

Doran et al. 2021 [74]

S

W

W

N/A

W

N/A

W

Dutch et al. 2012 [75]

S

W

W

N/A

M

N/A

W

Fell et al. 2017 [76]

M

M

M

M

S

N/A

S

Ford et al. 2018 [77]

M

W

W

N/A

M

N/A

W

Friedman et al. 2019 [31]

S

W

W

N/A

S

N/A

W

Fulde et al. 2015 [78]

S

W

W

N/A

S

N/A

W

Garius et al. 2020 [79]

W

M

W

N/A

S

N/A

W

George et al. 2018 [80]

M

M

W

N/A

M

N/A

M

Green et al. 2014 [81]

S

M

M

N/A

S

N/A

S

Grigg et al. 2018 [82]

W

W

M

N/A

W

N/A

W

Gruenewald et al. 2015 [83]

M

W

M

N/A

M

N/A

M

Ham et al. 2021 [84]

S

S

S

M

S

S

S

Hickey et al. 2012 [85]

W

M

W

N/A

M

M

W

Hoffman et al. 2017 [86]

S

M

M

N/A

S

N/A

S

Humphreys et al. 2013 [87]

S

M

S

N/A

M

N/A

S

Humphreys et al. 2014 [88]

S

M

W

N/A

S

N/A

M

Jackson et al. 2011 [89]

S

M

S

N/A

S

N/A

S

Kazbour et al. 2010 [90]

W

W

W

N/A

W

N/A

W

Khurana et al. 2021 [91]

S

M

S

N/A

S

N/A

S

Kirby et al. 2011 [92]

M

M

M

N/A

M

N/A

M

Klein et al. 2013 [93]

S

M

M

N/A

S

N/A

S

Kypri et al. 2011 [94]

S

M

M

N/A

M

N/A

S

Kypri et al. 2014 [95]

S

M

M

N/A

M

N/A

S

Kypri et al. 2020 [96]

S

M

S

N/A

M

N/A

S

Livingston et al. 2021 [26]

S

M

S

N/A

S

N/A

S

Lund et al. 2015 [97]

S

W

W

N/A

S

N/A

W

Mazerolle et al. 2012 [98]

S

M

M

N/A

M

N/A

S

Measham 2019 [28]

S

W

W

N/A

M

N/A

W

Measham & Turnbull 2021 [99]

S

M

W

N/A

W

N/A

W

Menéndez et al. 2015 [100]

S

M

M

N/A

M

N/A

S

Menéndez et al. 2015 [101]

S

M

M

N/A

S

N/A

S

Menéndez et al. 2017 [102]

S

M

M

N/A

S

N/A

S

Miller et al. 2011 [103]

S

M

M

N/A

S

N/A

S

Miller et al. 2012 [104]

S

M

M

N/A

S

N/A

S

Miller et al. 2014 [105]

S

M

S

N/A

S

N/A

S

Miller et al. 2020 [106]

S

M

M

N/A

S

N/A

S

Monezi et al. 2017 [107]

M

M

W

N/A

W

M

W

Moore et al. 2012 [108]

M

S

S

M

M

S

S

Moore et al. 2017 [109]

S

S

M

S

M

M

S

Munn et al. 2016 [110]

M

W

W

N/A

W

N/A

W

Navarro et al. 2013 [111]

S

S

S

W

M

W

W

Nepal et al. 2019 [112]

S

M

M

N/A

M

N/A

S

Norström et al. 2013 [113]

M

M

M

N/A

M

N/A

M

Norström et al. 2018 [114]

S

M

M

N/A

M

N/A

S

Palk et al. 2010 [115]

S

W

W

N/A

M

N/A

W

Palk et al. 2012 [116]

S

M

W

N/A

S

N/A

M

Paschall et al. 2021 [117]

M

W

W

N/A

W

N/A

W

Pliakas et al. 2018 [118]

S

M

M

N/A

M

N/A

S

Ragnarsdóttir et al. 2011 [119]

S

M

W

N/A

M

N/A

M

Randerson et al. 2018 [120]

M

M

W

N/A

M

N/A

M

Rivara et al. 2012 [121]

M

W

W

N/A

W

N/A

W

Rossow et al. 2012 [122]

S

M

M

N/A

M

N/A

S

Rowe et al. 2012 [123]

M

M

W

N/A

M

N/A

M

Skardhamar et al. 2016 [124]

M

M

M

N/A

M

N/A

S

Taylor et al. 2019 [125]

S

M

M

N/A

S

N/A

S

Taylor et al. 2020 [126]

S

M

M

N/A

S

N/A

S

Taylor et al. 2021 [127]

S

M

M

N/A

S

N/A

S

Taylor et al. 2021 [128]

S

M

M

N/A

S

N/A

S

Tesch et al. 2018 [129]

M

W

M

N/A

M

N/A

M

Tomedi et al. 2018 [130]

M

M

M

N/A

M

N/A

M

Trolldal et al. 2013 [131]

S

M

M

N/A

M

N/A

S

Ward et al. 2018 [32]

S

W

W

N/A

M

N/A

W

Wiggers et al. 2021 [132]

M

M

M

N/A

M

N/A

M

Wood et al. 2010 [133]

S

W

W

N/A

W

m

W

Xu et al. 2012 [134]

S

M

M

N/A

S

N/A

S

Young-Wolff et al. 2013 [135]

S

M

S

N/A

M

N/A

S

Zawisza et al. 2020 [136]

W

W

W

N/A

W

N/A

W

Zhang et al. 2015 [137]

S

M

S

N/A

S

N/A

S

  1. Note. S: Strong; M: Moderate; W: Weak; N/A: Not applicable
  2. *Ratings for blinding and withdrawals were only applicable where the study was an RCT design
Back to article page

Harm Reduction Journal

ISSN: 1477-7517